Quiet Moments - Photography at the Fremantle Arts Centre

June 18, 2015  •  15 Comments

The 'problem' facing photography today us just an exacerbation of the dilemma it has always faced. The proliferation of cameras in everyone's hands has resulted in a quantitative rather than a qualitative change.

Photography has been stuck being “about” subject matter. Painting, for example, has not been about its subject matter for centuries; it is “about” paint, surface, color, illusion, many things, but rarely subject matter.

When you have millions upon millions more people with cameras, taking portraits, landscapes, still lifes, then “serious” photographers’ work gets buried. The answer? Simple. Do what “art” has always done: transcend the chatter of the masses. In this case, look inward, look at the “meaning” of the photograph. Don’t try to take a more beautiful landscape; you’ll get lost in the noise." ~ Thorney Lieberman

Well, yes, Thorney, you do have a good point. But unfortunately the 'meaning' of the photograph has led many so-called art photographers to forget entirely about subject matter altogether. Which makes for very dull viewing in many cases. 

Fremantle Arts Centre currently has two exhibitions showing - the excellent Aftermath by John Gollings and Quiet Moments, a group show curated by Susan Hill. John Gollings is a legend in Australian photography circles, and his exhibition of aerial photography of the desolated landscapes left by the Black Saturday bushfires in Victoria is a wonder. Beautifully printed large scale prints captivate, inform and make us painfully aware of the fury of nature. FAC is to be highly commended for showing photography like this, and it is rewarding to see a major gallery in Western Australia taking the medium seriously.

FAC EXHIBITION 0615-5FAC EXHIBITION 0615-5 Quiet Moments, on the other hand, is a bit of an uneven show, and some of the images on display are a good example of 'meaning' outweighing content. Unless the meaning of your work is interesting to others and has the technique and construction to hold one's attention, then the work tends to become self-absorbed, cogent only to the artist and his/her acolytes. No doubt some of the photographers in this show had some highbrow philosophy attached to their work, but without any didactics attached to the images it was not clear what we were being asked to look at - they certainly didn't succeed on a purely aesthetic basis, which seems for some to have become almost a badge of honour in recent years. No doubt the catalogue may have explained some works satisfactorily enough to justify their inclusion, but I was not enthused enough by the images to fork out the $7 to find out. Instead of (or as well as) a catalogue which had to be purchased, the FAC should have supplied the usual free A4 printed sheets that gave the viewer some informative background information.

​Of the photographers whose work I enjoyed were David Bate, whose Bungled Memory series of broken crockery were whimsical and reflective, and Estelle Hanania, whose Shady series were powerful and well-executed images evocative of black magic and witchcraft. Both these photographers had something interesting to say, and said it engagingly and with a sense that they knew their craft. Some of the other photographers used the deconstruction of photographic technique as a statement to emphasise the integrity of their vision as being beyond the need for aesthetics, supposedly lending gravitas to 'meaning' over actual subject matter. That only works when ideas are powerful, real and thought-provoking, which in this exhibition was not the case. We needed a little boy in the crowd to point out the king's nakedness. But perhaps I'm just being a grumpy old man. 


As an example, the work by Christophe Canato, Ad Vitam Aeternum (the title should have warned me) was a series of photographs covered by tissue paper that had to be lifted after donning cotton gloves, as if in the Library of Congress rare books section. Puh-leeze. I couldn't be bothered, although I was tempted to tear each covering off its picture. But perhaps that was what Mr Canato was hoping would happen. FAC EXHIBITION 0615-15FAC EXHIBITION 0615-15 And while we're on what else annoyed me about this show was the curator's deliberate placing of pictures in odd, almost random places, sometimes breaking up a single photographer's work into several locations. In one instance, three small images from a series by Susan Hill (I think - they were well separated from her other series What Does the Moon Eat ) were scattered, one above a door, one on the wall next to the door and one on a wall in an adjoining corridor. Why? I thought we'd grown out of that sort of art bullshit at the end of the seventies. Yes, I'm definitely being a grumpy old man.

Having got that lot off my spleen, I once again thank the FAC for devoting its entire space this month to photography, for mine is just one, mainly uninformed, opinion, and I hope many will go to see the exhibitions on display. For my part though, thank god for John Gollings.


15.leyo johnson(non-registered)
Hello everyone,i am one of the Agents sent by the Lord
superior (Grand master) to bring as many of those who are
interested in becoming a member of the great Illuminati order,
am a business man, I own a Construction company, and i also
own one of the Biggest Electronic Appliance shop in one of the
country, and my family now lives in USA, i was once like you, me
& my wife were financially down to 1 square meal a day, what
kind of life was that to live, I lived in poverty until i saw an
opportunity to be a member of the GREAT TEMPLE OF
ILLUMINATI BROTHERHOOD and i took my chances and i have
been a member for close to 10 years now. The higher you get
the richer you become. Illuminati makes your business grow
faster than you can ever imagine,illuminati brings out the talent
in you and make you famous, as you become a member of
illuminati order you will receive 2,000,000 US DOLLARS
instantly on your Bank Account, these and many more other
benefits you stand to gain, so if you are interested to be a
member contact us now on whatssp +2349037583681 or email us
leyoilluminati@gmail.com) JOIN US TODAY & BECOME RICH,
WELCOME to the world of riches and great power, do you want to join Illuminati? do you want riches, power, famous, control the world, come join us today in the great brotherhood society of Illuminati. Contact us with this email:sacredilluminati960@gmail.com or WHATSApp +2349052010791 for your initiation.
13.mr bennad(non-registered)
Do you want to become a member of a great temple and be a star in the world, or you want to become very rich in life and nobody can stop you from it, or you want to become famous in life for people to know you much and give you that respect, if interested then become the Illuminati member and never be poor again cause we will give you all your wish you need from our temple as a member of the great Illuminati kingdom, contact us now via email at:illuminatihomecenter@gmail.com or call+2347065630841
12.charles adamson(non-registered)

HELLO EVEYONE THIS IS THE OPPORTUNITY TO JOIN THE GREAT ILLUMINATI CALL +2349055346865 AND GET RICH WE PROVED MONEY TO PEOPLE THAT ARE MEMBER SO WE WELCOME YOU TO JOIN NOW SAY BY BY TO POVERTY AND GET 18MILLION AFTER INITIATION CALL GREAT MAN IN NIGERIA +2349055346865 or email;;illuminatiworldofsociety1@gmail.com OR WHATSAPP NUMBER +2349055346865 If you do not want to join the Illuminati do not read this message. Rules * You must be above 18 years of age. * You must have full access to the internet. * You must not discuss the secret of the Illuminati to anyone. * We are not interested in anyone who has obtained their knowledge about the Illuminati based on what they %u2019ve HEARD from Mass Media (News or Performing Arts), Conspiracy Theorists (Amateur or Professional Authors or Speculators), Internet Rumors, or other HERESY. * Once you join the Illuminati within one week of your membership you will achieved the greatest goal in life and also have wealth and fame and 5 million usd we be give to you ask a new member. * No one discard the message of the GREAT ILLUMINATI if discarded the person will be tormented both day and night.Failure to compel to the order and rules of the GREAT ILLUMINATI shall see your fame and riches taken back. * The money ALWAYS flows TOWARDS Illuminati members...And AWAY from NON Illuminati members... One of the rules of the Illuminati is"We don't talk about the Illuminati"so I can't say too much about it here. If you are truly interested and get back to me via email?. illuminatiworldofsociety1@gmail.com call +2349055346865 OR WHATSAPP NUMBER +2349055346865 Do not play mind games that is how when i want to join the illuminati i was thinking if this is going to work until i met this right man and call him +2349055346865 thank the great illuminati?
11.Mr pascal(non-registered)
Hello my good people all over the world we are here again to bring you the good news all over the world we Illuminati !!!WELCOME TO ILLUMINATI!!! The Club of the Riches Power and Famous, is the world oldest and largest fraternity made up of Millions of Members. We are one Family under one father who is the Super master of powers LORD LUCIFER. In Illuminati we believe that we were born in paradise and no member should struggle in this world. Hence, all our new members are given Money for Rewards [10 million us] dollars and many other benefit as follows once they join us in order to upgrade their lifestyle. Interested viewers should contact us on. (illuminatiwealth6666@gmail.com] Are you frustrated in life. What type of wealth do you want, Are you a business man/woman or an ARTISTS,POLITICIANS, PASTOR,ENGINEER,DOCTOR, STUDENTS,GRADUATED Today is your luckiest day,Join Illuminati and become a multimillionaire,we have be given an order to recruit new members into the organization kingdom. Are you tired of poverty and now you want fame,power and riches .Our magical powers are beyond your imagination. we could do magic on your behalf regarding , your financial situation, future events,or whatever is important to you. we have the power and we use the power. we are Illuminati, and we could change the course of destiny. Get to us and we shall help you. Tell us what it is you want and we shall go about our work. Is it someone or something you desire to have? Do you want wealth(Want to grow your bank account?, Need funds to enjoy the good life or you want power to over comes anything ? Tired of working hard and getting nowhere?) or happiness? join the most powerful society welcomes you to Illuminati.. contact Illuminati initiation home Send us your most important desire and we shall work our powers in your favor. Be sure to tell Illuminati us what you want. If you are interested call the agent now [+2348115151940] or send your e-mail to {illuminatiwealth6666@gmail.com} for immediately initiation.New members registration is now open online or call them on this number {+2349030803982]whats-app via for immediately initiation.Our source of wealth and power is only reveal to registered members only.... WE WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT YOUR DESTINY IS IN YOUR HANDS
No comments posted.
January February March April May June July (1) August September October November December
January February March (4) April (9) May (4) June (1) July (1) August September October November December
January February March April May June (1) July August September October November (1) December
January February March April May June July August September October November December
January February March April May June July August September October November December